Edinburgh suffer late Semi-Final defeat
The dreams of a first-ever Guinness PRO14 final were dashed on Saturday night as Ulster's Ian Madigan snatched victory from the jaws of defeat with an 80th minute walk off winner.
In a heartbreaking loss, Edinburgh had shot out to an early lead with tries from Scotland stars Stuart McInally and Darcy Graham, however the visitors fought back with second-half scores from Rob Lyttle and Rob Herring.
The hosts looked to be on their way to Dublin when Chris Dean powered over with 20 minutes remaining to stretch the score further, however when John Andrew bruised over late on, the score was levelled 19-19.
Then - with the clock in red - Edinburgh were penalised inside their own half and up stepped Madigan to calmly slot home the winner for the Belfast side.

It was a scrum-filled opening 10 minutes, as both sides struggled to gain footing amidst continuous collapses. After gaining possession through a penalty against Ulster prop Eric O’Sullivan, the capital side were looking a lot more comfortable on the ball than they had in the previous week’s fixture, playing with a lot more energy and creativity.
An extended period of possession allowed Edinburgh to gain ground through a barrage of attacking play – and as the phases continued to build, the Ulster defensive line would finally give way.
Skipper Stuart McInally was the man to take the spoils, as he spotted the gap following a maul, shrugging off his tackler and crashing down on the whitewash for his first try of the season – and the first of the match. (5-0)
The game was victim to a similar period of scoreless play as the previous week's 1872 Cup fixture, albeit with a much more inspired and entertaining brand of rugby on display. Ulster weren’t taking Edinburgh’s lead lying down, and a worrying period of play brought them to within metres of the try-line but the home side’s defensive line held strong, with relentless pressure keeping the opposition at bay, and the score-line untouched.
Edinburgh themselves were looking energised, and hungry for another try. This almost came in the final seconds of the first half, when Chris Dean burst away deep into opposition territory.
The score looked almost inevitable were it not for a last-gasp tackle, which brought Dean down before he could find the offload. Although only 5-0 at the break, the game certainly didn’t feel like it – with both sides offering no quarter in a lively and compelling, but tense and tightly-contested affair.
This appetite for points carried through to the second half, with McInally once again leading the charge. Brought down metres from the line, a series of pick-and-gos culminated in Nic Groom finding Jaco van der Walt, who led the defenders his way before popping the ball over to the waiting Darcy Graham who raced over for Edinburgh’s second try. Van der Walt was quick to add the extras to put some distance between the scores. (12-0)

The game really kicked into gear from here on out, as Ulster looked to liven their attacks with risky long passes and precise runs into the half. These opportunities eventually paid off as Rob Lyttle received the ball out wide and skipped his way past his marker, running in Ulster’s first try. The conversion from Billy Burns put the score at 12-7 and brought Ulster right back into contention.
Edinburgh hit back straight away though, as intense pressure from phase play led to an outstanding break from Hamish Watson. The forward fought his way through numerous outstretched arms before finding Chris Dean, who was left to simply run in and put five more points – shortly increased to seven courtesy of the boot of van der Walt. (19-7)
Ulster’s determination and drive was admirable though, as they responded immediately through a Rob Herring try, after the hooker spun away from a short side maul to crash down, making it 19-12.
Both sides were throwing everything they had at each other for the last 20 minutes in a desperate attempt to put the game to bed. It would take till the 74th minute before Ulster were the successful side in their bombardment of the Edinburgh try-line as John Andrew found his way through a mess of bodies to touch down. The pressure was on Ian Madigan, who slotted the conversion to make it all square at 19-19 with just five minutes to go.
There was just one minute left on the clock, when a penalty was called in Ulster’s favour. Ian Madigan was the man who stepped up to take it, sealing Edinburgh’s fate, and bringing the curtain down on a truly astounding but heartrending semi-final – the score at the death 19-22.
live commentary 7:35 PM Saturday 5 Sep 2020
‘{{ time.substring(0, 2) }}
Half-time
Full-time
{{ event.type }}
Kick-off 7:35 PM
We're sorry, we're not able to retrieve this information at the moment, please try back later
Edinburgh
-
George Taylor
23. Replacement0metres made
21MINUTES PLAYED
3TACKLES MADE
0COMPLETE PASSES
-
Nathan Chamberlain
22. Replacement0metres made
0MINUTES PLAYED
0TACKLES MADE
0COMPLETE PASSES
-
Charlie Shiel
21. Replacement0metres made
4MINUTES PLAYED
0TACKLES MADE
1COMPLETE PASSES
-
Jamie Ritchie
20. Replacement0metres made
16MINUTES PLAYED
4TACKLES MADE
0COMPLETE PASSES
-
Andrew Davidson
19. Replacement0metres made
11MINUTES PLAYED
0TACKLES MADE
0COMPLETE PASSES
-
Simon Berghan
18. Replacement9metres made
32MINUTES PLAYED
11TACKLES MADE
0COMPLETE PASSES
-
Pierre Schoeman
17. Replacement0metres made
28MINUTES PLAYED
10TACKLES MADE
1COMPLETE PASSES
-
Michael Willemse
16. Replacement0metres made
11MINUTES PLAYED
3TACKLES MADE
0COMPLETE PASSES
-
Viliame Mata
8. Number 832metres made
64MINUTES PLAYED
6TACKLES MADE
3COMPLETE PASSES
-
Hamish Watson
7. Back-row16metres made
80MINUTES PLAYED
13TACKLES MADE
11COMPLETE PASSES
-
Magnus Bradbury
6. Back-row10metres made
80MINUTES PLAYED
20TACKLES MADE
0COMPLETE PASSES
-
Grant Gilchrist
5. Second-row4metres made
80MINUTES PLAYED
20TACKLES MADE
6COMPLETE PASSES
-
Ben Toolis
4. Second-row3metres made
69MINUTES PLAYED
9TACKLES MADE
5COMPLETE PASSES
-
WP Nel
3. Tighthead prop0metres made
48MINUTES PLAYED
11TACKLES MADE
0COMPLETE PASSES
-
Stuart McInally
2. Hooker23metres made
69MINUTES PLAYED
14TACKLES MADE
4COMPLETE PASSES
-
Rory Sutherland
1. Loosehead prop4metres made
52MINUTES PLAYED
9TACKLES MADE
0COMPLETE PASSES
-
Nic Groom
9. Scrum-half1metres made
76MINUTES PLAYED
3TACKLES MADE
78COMPLETE PASSES
-
Jaco van der Walt
10. Stand-off1metres made
80MINUTES PLAYED
17TACKLES MADE
24COMPLETE PASSES
-
Duhan van der Merwe
11. Wing101metres made
80MINUTES PLAYED
6TACKLES MADE
0COMPLETE PASSES
-
Chris Dean
12. Inside-centre37metres made
59MINUTES PLAYED
8TACKLES MADE
10COMPLETE PASSES
-
Mark Bennett
13. Outside-centre42metres made
80MINUTES PLAYED
5TACKLES MADE
6COMPLETE PASSES
-
Darcy Graham
14. Wing21metres made
80MINUTES PLAYED
8TACKLES MADE
1COMPLETE PASSES
-
Blair Kinghorn
15. Full-back41metres made
80MINUTES PLAYED
5TACKLES MADE
3COMPLETE PASSES
Ulster
-
Jacob Stockdale
15. Full-back61metres made
80MINUTES PLAYED
1TACKLES MADE
3COMPLETE PASSES
-
Louis Ludik
14. Wing5metres made
40MINUTES PLAYED
2TACKLES MADE
1COMPLETE PASSES
-
James Hume
13. Outside-centre11metres made
80MINUTES PLAYED
4TACKLES MADE
10COMPLETE PASSES
-
Stuart McCloskey
12. Inside-centre30metres made
80MINUTES PLAYED
5TACKLES MADE
10COMPLETE PASSES
-
Rob Lyttle
11. Wing78metres made
80MINUTES PLAYED
3TACKLES MADE
4COMPLETE PASSES
-
Billy Burns
10. Stand-off2metres made
70MINUTES PLAYED
8TACKLES MADE
21COMPLETE PASSES
-
John Cooney
9. Scrum-half3metres made
40MINUTES PLAYED
6TACKLES MADE
41COMPLETE PASSES
-
Eric O'Sullivan
1. Loosehead prop3metres made
52MINUTES PLAYED
12TACKLES MADE
1COMPLETE PASSES
-
Rob Herring
2. Hooker0metres made
70MINUTES PLAYED
16TACKLES MADE
1COMPLETE PASSES
-
Tom O'Toole
3. Tighthead prop3metres made
52MINUTES PLAYED
12TACKLES MADE
1COMPLETE PASSES
-
Alan O'Connor
4. Second-row4metres made
80MINUTES PLAYED
11TACKLES MADE
2COMPLETE PASSES
-
Sam Carter
5. Second-row3metres made
49MINUTES PLAYED
8TACKLES MADE
0COMPLETE PASSES
-
Matthew Rea
6. Back-row20metres made
80MINUTES PLAYED
12TACKLES MADE
7COMPLETE PASSES
-
Jordi Murphy
7. Back-row0metres made
40MINUTES PLAYED
13TACKLES MADE
2COMPLETE PASSES
-
Marcell Coetzee
8. Number 819metres made
80MINUTES PLAYED
10TACKLES MADE
4COMPLETE PASSES
-
John Andrew
16. Replacement5metres made
10MINUTES PLAYED
1TACKLES MADE
0COMPLETE PASSES
-
Jack McGrath
17. Replacement8metres made
28MINUTES PLAYED
3TACKLES MADE
3COMPLETE PASSES
-
Marty Moore
18. Replacement6metres made
28MINUTES PLAYED
2TACKLES MADE
2COMPLETE PASSES
-
Kieran Treadwell
19. Replacement1metres made
31MINUTES PLAYED
1TACKLES MADE
4COMPLETE PASSES
-
Sean Reidy
20. Replacement7metres made
40MINUTES PLAYED
4TACKLES MADE
3COMPLETE PASSES
-
Alby Mathewson
21. Replacement9metres made
40MINUTES PLAYED
2TACKLES MADE
70COMPLETE PASSES
-
Ian Madigan
22. Replacement0metres made
10MINUTES PLAYED
0TACKLES MADE
3COMPLETE PASSES
-
Michael Lowry
23. Replacement34metres made
40MINUTES PLAYED
0TACKLES MADE
5COMPLETE PASSES
Your browser is out of date.
Update your browser to view this website correctly.
CHECK HERE FOR LATEST VERSIONSRead more information about browsers and how to upgrade yours